When You Become a Not Person
- Gareth Sidwell
- Sep 7
- 5 min read
You wake up and realize you can't introduce yourself beyond your name.
You've become what one university student described as "a black blob" or "a not-person." An empty space that people look through. You exist, but barely.
This identity erasure affects more men than we acknowledge. **Research shows that 95% of incels report depression compared to just 28% of the general population.** The numbers reveal something critical about how identity crisis and mental health intertwine.
But the real question isn't about statistics. It's about understanding what creates this psychological void and how you escape it.
The Echo Chamber of Horrors
Your identity vacuum didn't happen overnight.
You probably started by genuinely looking for self-improvement or dating advice. The algorithm pushed you toward male influencer content. Some told you that you were handsome but needed to be powerful. Others said you didn't make the grade and pushed you toward black-pill content.
Maybe you experienced rejection and interpreted it as being about your looks. You started venting anger online and got pushed toward darker content.
Or you found snippets on social media that created interest, and you sought them out.
All roads led to the same destination: forums that justified your worst feelings about yourself.
Here's what happens in these spaces. You stop seeing yourself as an individual and become part of an anonymous collective who think and feel like you do. When your emotions and psychology get validated by the group, you only seek confirmation of being ugly or terrible.
You trade individual identity for group identity.
The forums become an echo chamber of horrors and self-loathing that gets projected onto women. Members tell each other they're not worthy of affection or attention. You identify with the worst parts you feel about yourself, and the group reflects it back at you.
This creates a negative self-fulfilling prophecy. You stop looking for counter-arguments and instead look for confirmation of your worst feelings and self-image.
Why Rejection Becomes Fatal
Rejection hurts because you create an identity for the person you're attracted to, then project your feelings and needs onto them.
When you ask someone out (or don't ask), the rejection feels devastating. You don't see the many possible reasons for it. Just because you're attracted to them doesn't mean they're attracted to you. They might have a boyfriend, might be recovering from a breakup, might be dealing with their own issues.
You see this as a fatal blow.
So you try to avoid this feeling ever again. You miss out on the growing experience of learning how to interact with women, learning about yourself, and learning how to actively engage with people in general.
It's much easier to blame someone else than take accountability for yourself and look at ways to improve.
This avoidance creates the identity vacuum. Without regular social interactions, new experiences, or active pursuit of interests, you become unable to develop or maintain the personality markers that typically define individual identity.
Identity formation is a key developmental task for adolescence and emerging adulthood. When you withdraw from social interaction, you stop the natural process of discovering who you are.
The Liberation Moment
Something interesting happens in these toxic forums that most people don't know about.
Men start to see errors in the code. A woman smiles at them or genuinely chats with them. This makes them question the echo chamber. If women will talk to me, they think, then I can't be this horrible invisible or unwanted person that I think I am.
When other people post about how women don't talk to them because of their looks, it starts a fracture in their belief system.
Here's the fascinating part: the forums ban people who start questioning the ideology.
They fear their matrix will be shattered if men start saying "hey, it's actually not as bad as we think." The adherents don't want their beliefs questioned. They'd rather kill the messenger than hear the message.
This banning becomes accidental liberation. It forces men to question other aspects of the ideology when they're kicked out of their toxic support system.
The Critical Window
You're most vulnerable in the moment after being banned or choosing to leave.
You've lost your toxic community but haven't built a healthy identity yet. You're questioning everything but suddenly have no community at all.
This is where many men either go back to the forums or fall into even darker spaces. The identity vacuum remains, but now you're completely alone.
There's a "leaving incel" forum on Reddit where men show signs that they want to investigate change or are looking for practical advice and support. These spaces become crucial bridges.
Some of these men have missed out on years of socialization that would have helped them develop a healthier self-image and better equipped them for relationships and life in general.
Rebuilding Your Individual Identity
When you're essentially socially frozen at age 16 but now 22, rebuilding feels overwhelming.
Peer support becomes essential. Knowing that other men have experienced this gives you an opportunity to not feel excluded. You're not the only one who lost years to this identity crisis.
The skills can be learned through 1:1 support or self-learning tools that let you learn at your own pace. Psychoeducation helps develop healthy attitudes, build self-esteem, and create an identity and world you want to live in.
The goal isn't to shame you for what you've lost. It's to help you discover what you can build.
**Online communities can fill important social and emotional needs, but they can also require participating in extremist language and ideas to maintain membership.** The key is finding communities that reward growth rather than stagnation.
From Black Blob to Individual
You don't have to stay a "not-person."
Your identity wasn't destroyed. It was put on pause while you tried to avoid the pain of rejection and growth. The forums offered a false solution: blame others instead of facing the discomfort of developing yourself.
But development requires discomfort. It requires risking rejection, making mistakes, and learning from them.
The antidote to the identity vacuum is connection. Not the toxic connection of shared hatred, but the authentic connection of shared growth.
You can learn to interact with people again. You can develop interests and preferences. You can build an identity based on what you want to create rather than what you want to avoid.
The forums taught you that you were fundamentally flawed and that women were the enemy. Both beliefs are lies designed to keep you trapped in the echo chamber of horrors.
You're not broken. You're not fundamentally flawed. You're someone who got lost and needs to find their way back to themselves.
The path back starts with recognizing that the black blob isn't your true identity. It's what happens when you stop trying to discover who you actually are.
Your real identity is waiting for you to start building it again. With humor, love, and excitement for what's possible when you step out of the echo chamber and back into the world.



Comments